Thirty-something sisters Cara and Amy Martin have a tradition of spending Christmases together in New York City, where they make a Christmas wish that always comes true. This year, they both wished to meet their soulmate by Christmas, and while Amy has already found hers, Cara is still searching. When she meets Chace, who shares her love for obscure New York Christmas traditions, she thinks she's found her match. However, she loses touch with him and instead finds Michael, a talented writer who doesn't celebrate traditional Christmas anymore. As Cara tries to locate Chace, she and Michael grow closer, and she must decide between her search for her soulmate and her emerging feelings for Michael.
Christmas Plus One
A year after making a pact to find their soulmates by Christmas, sisters Cara and Amy's lives take unexpected turns.
