The movie tells the story of Amish Eli Weaver, whose wife Barbara is found shot dead in their bed. As the Wayne County Sheriff's Department investigates the murder, they uncover a complex web of relationships and secrets within the Amish community. Through flashbacks, it becomes clear that Eli and Barbara's marriage was not without its challenges, as Barbara had initially wanted to marry for romantic love, which is not the Amish way. The investigators, Detectives London and Maxwell, suspect Eli of the crime, but they struggle to find evidence due to the Amish community's lack of digital footprint and reliance on traditional communication methods. As they dig deeper, they discover that Eli had a secret life as the "Amish Stud," with a group of women outside the community.