Noah Funk, a newly-elected Mennonite pastor, decides to betray a fellow Mennonite to the police to rid his community of drug traffickers. However, this action triggers an ultimatum from mob leader Eli Voss, forcing Noah to get involved in the illegal operation to protect his family. Despite working for the mob, Noah secretly gathers evidence to dismantle the organization, struggling to save his soul and complete his mission. He receives help from an unlikely source, his high school nemesis, local cop Bronco Novak, who sees the case as his ticket to redemption.
Noah Funk, a respected Mennonite, takes on the role of pastor for his church ...