Everybody Wants to Be Italian

In a small Boston neighborhood, a fish market owner named Jake struggles to move on from his unrequited love for his ex-girlfriend Isabella, who is now married with three children. Despite this, Jake continues to claim she's his girlfriend to those around him, including Marisa, a veterinarian he meets at an Italian singles club. As Jake navigates his friendship with Marisa, he begins to question whether reality might be more fulfilling than fantasy, but he's also uncertain about what the future holds for both women and his own identity.